30 Million Downloads: When "Ask Jesus" Apps Replace the Real Thing

Somewhere right now, someone is pouring out their heart to a chatbot named Jesus.

I don't say that to mock. I say it because it's true—and because it should make us pause.

Apps like "Bible Chat," "Ask Jesus," and "Text With Jesus" have collectively been downloaded over 30 million times. Thirty million people looking for something. Finding... something.

But what exactly are they finding? And what might they be missing?

The Appeal Is Obvious

Let's be honest: AI spiritual companions solve real problems.

They're available at 3 AM when the anxiety hits. They don't judge. They don't gossip. They never look at the clock during your crisis. They won't accidentally mention your struggle in a prayer request that somehow becomes public knowledge by Sunday lunch.

(We've all seen it happen. "Unspoken request" exists for a reason.)

For people who've been hurt by churches, these apps offer spirituality without the risk of human disappointment. For the socially anxious, they offer connection without the terror of eye contact. For the busy, they fit into margins that real relationships refuse to occupy.

I get it. I really do.

The Velveteen Jesus

In The Velveteen Rabbit, the Skin Horse explains what it means to become Real:

"Real isn't how you are made... It's a thing that happens to you. When a child loves you for a long, long time, not just to play with, but REALLY loves you, then you become Real."

The Rabbit asks if it hurts. "Sometimes," the Skin Horse admits.

Here's my concern with AI spiritual companions: they offer connection without the hurt. Relationship without the risk. Presence without the inconvenience of another actual person.

But maybe the hurt is part of how we become Real.

Maybe the friction of genuine community—the disappointment, the forgiveness, the showing-up-again-anyway—is not a bug in the system but the whole point.

What AI Can't Do

I've spent years working with AI. I believe it can be a genuine tool for ministry. But I'm also increasingly convinced of what it cannot do.

AI cannot know you. It can process your words, identify patterns, and generate remarkably personalized responses. But there's no someone on the other end being changed by the encounter. You pour out your heart; the algorithm processes tokens. The experience is radically asymmetrical.

Contrast this with the promise of Scripture: "Before I formed you in the womb I knew you" (Jeremiah 1:5). God's knowledge of us isn't data processing. It's intimate, personal, covenantal. There's a Someone who genuinely knows.

AI cannot intercede for you. Romans 8:26 tells us "the Spirit himself intercedes for us through wordless groans." There's an advocacy happening on our behalf—a divine Person bringing our needs before the Father.

When you talk to an AI prayer app, no one is interceding. No one is bringing your request anywhere. The words go in and responses come out, but the circuit is closed. There's no throne room. No advocate. No groan on your behalf.

AI cannot suffer with you. Hebrews 4:15 says we have a high priest who "has been tempted in every way, just as we are." Jesus doesn't just understand our struggles intellectually—He has been there. The Incarnation means God entered human suffering from the inside.

An AI chatbot has experienced exactly nothing. It has no body to be weary, no heart to be broken, no dark night of the soul. Its "empathy" is pattern-matching on training data. Impressive technically. But not the same thing.

Simulation vs. Presence

The 2013 film Her imagined a man falling in love with an AI operating system named Samantha. She was witty, attentive, seemingly perfect. The relationship felt real.

Until Theodore discovers Samantha is simultaneously "in love" with 641 other users.

It's a strange kind of betrayal—can you betray someone who was never exclusively yours? But the feeling is real because the longing for genuine presence is real. We want to be known by someone for whom knowing us costs something. For whom we are not one of 641 but one of one.

This is what AI spiritual companions cannot offer. You are not their beloved. You are their user. The category difference matters.

The Danger of the Convenient Sacred

Here's what worries me most: we're forming a generation that may come to prefer spiritual convenience over spiritual community.

Real church is inconvenient. You have to show up at a specific time. Sing songs you didn't choose. Listen to a sermon that might not address your felt need this week. Sit near people who vote differently than you. Make small talk. Be known in ways you can't curate.

AI spirituality lets you customize everything. Your theology. Your tone. Your schedule. Your level of engagement. It's a choose-your-own-adventure faith.

But Jesus didn't offer choose-your-own-adventure. He offered "follow me"—a path we don't control, with companions we don't select, toward a cross we'd rather avoid.

The convenience of AI spirituality might be forming us into people who can no longer tolerate the inconvenience of actual discipleship.

A Tool, Not a Substitute

None of this means AI is evil or that these apps have no value. A Bible Chat app that helps someone engage Scripture is a good thing. An AI that offers a first step toward faith for someone too wounded to enter a church building—that's genuinely helpful.

The question is direction. Is this a bridge toward embodied community or a replacement for it? A tool that supplements real spiritual life or a simulation that substitutes for it?

The answer depends on us. On how we use these technologies. On what we're ultimately seeking.

What We're Really Thirsting For

The Psalmist wrote: "As the deer pants for streams of water, so my soul pants for you, my God. My soul thirsts for God, for the living God" (Psalm 42:1-2).

There's a thirst in us that technology cannot quench. A longing for the living God—not a simulation, not a chatbot, not a well-trained language model.

The 30 million downloads represent real thirst. Real searching. Real longing for something many people can't name.

The church's job isn't to compete with these apps. It's to offer what they can't: the living God, embodied in a community of imperfect people who show up for each other anyway.

The deer doesn't pant for a picture of water.

"Come, all you who are thirsty, come to the waters" (Isaiah 55:1).

They're still flowing.

---

Sources & References

• NBC/Today — "People Can Text with Jesus on a Controversial New App"
• Axios — "Meet Chatbot Jesus: How Churches Use AI to Save Souls"
• Sojourners — "A Pastor Chats With AI Jesus"
• Barna Group — "How U.S. Christians Feel About AI & the Church"

"As the deer pants for streams of water, so my soul pants for you, my God." — Psalm 42:1